Sanjay Dutt vs Major Manish Pitambare?

A friend recently made a complaint to me: While Major Manish Pitambare laid his life fighting against terrorists in Kashmir, our news channels were broadcasting how Sanjay Dutt was acquitted of ‘Terrorist Charges’. He said that we don’t respect our soldiers enough, and that men who held guns should be punished, rather than advertised. Here is my reaction to his writeup.
There are hundreds of people who inspire us… with various things. And knowingly or unknowingly we are curious about them. The foremost for Indians are Indian Cricketers (or should I say BCCI cricketers) and film stars. It was being discussed in Parliament for various reasons including making sure that Sharad Pawar (President of NCP) gets some bashing.
We elect our politicians, and we deserve everything they do to us – from not discussing military to making India corrupt.
Fact is that most number of innocent people in Kashmir (since its inception into Independent India) have been killed by none other than Indian Military (Arundhati Roy’s An Ordinary Person’s Guide to Empire).
A Military Officer has given his life to make sure that India isn’t harmed by a militant, and we call him a hero. Please note that the militants group will also call their fellow militant a hero. It is just that we believe in different philosophies. Unfortunately, all our philosophies are based on our conditioning.
Our conditioning says that women should be at home, families should be together, gods and demons exist, find a job, have children etc etc etc etc. Just because a military officer and a militant have been subjected to conditionings they are on the opposite side. Fact is they both are KILLERS. And if one doesn’t kill the other, the other will kill this one.
Fact is both are doing their jobs. The jobs have been given to them by different OFFICERs and POLITICIANS who have been elected (by people like us). Or some such politicians force others to elect them (because people like us are not strong enough).
Sanjay Dutt was doing his job to get out of his troubles. Just try and get glimpse of military officers who are doubted in War Room Leak case. They will be doing their best to get out of the case as well. The news people do their job. If you don’t like it, you switch off the channels or filter news in a nice way so that you completely understand what that news means.
Say for example:
If someone says, that Saurav Ganguly’s experience is needed in ODI cricket, we should understand that people like Sehwag and Bhajji are doing their best so that India loses and some short coming can be found. And if the same time Politicians make a hash of it in the Parliament, all we need to understand that Ganguly, politicians, Sehwag, Bhajji are all involved. Or that all these things will result in Ganguly’s inclusion or that they are all different things need to be seen that way.
But who cares…we like fast conclusions rather than finding questions to be answered.
Well, Parliamentarians were doing there job. They were talking about the MOST INSPIRING thing for most Indians(i’m not generalizing it, it is a fact, i think many Indians will tell you the same answer). Greg Chappel is doing his job as well. All are doing their jobs well (Of course, except me…I’m writing this in Officer Hours).
Seeing negatives in one is fine, but finding faults without actually understanding things, just because you happen to know ‘history’ is wrong.
All I want is that all of us to understand that in going with the flow we judge someone saying someone is RIGHT and some one is WRONG.
Judging someone, based on what someone else has achieved is always a biased decision. It is an unnecessary (and a convenient) comparison. From comparison comes, competition. No wonder, teenagers hang themselves in hostel rooms unable to get over this stupid thing called “comparison and competition”.
Just because a military officer has given his life, why should Sanjay Dutt be not allowed to appeal or why should TV news cover that. That’s his legal right, as much as say, a Manu Sharma in Jessica Lall’s case. Otherwise Democracy and Free Will do not exist. That’s what I wanted to say.
If India and Indians have to raise above these conditions, then probably we are expecting PERFECTION. Honestly PERFECTION needs to perfected by time. Lets change, every moment, try and see things WHOLLY and then judge. If we make our ONE sided judgements and feelings our bosses, we will end up being only a SO CALLED DEMOCRACY not an exact DEMOCRACY.
Let us salute those who have brought Television to India, or those who thought of Constitution. Lets salute the judicial system that allows Judgment for all, even for a Manu Sharma. Let us be inspired by a person who has been playing cricket for 17 years and is still not tired(though plays awfully more often). Let us be inspired by a drug addict who submitted himself to few BHAIS and probably is trying to make a come back to life.
If we do not salute them and do not feel inspired by them, then we have no right to salute a MILITARY OFFICER, who has died to make sure that many such Drug Addicts, will come back to Normal Life and inspire ordinary people like us, who only have one way to go – secured and a conditioned life.
Let us all appreciate the smaller achievements of life, otherwise, life in present moment is so small that it is gone even before you realize.
But in the end I have question is it really Sanjay Dutt vs Major Manish Pitambare
OR
Us vs Our Lifeless Side?
Somebody should tell me…
Well said Prakash…I stretch your comments to say that when we are with our innerself, we are no longer superior or inferior…we are what we are…
SKPeta
20 Dec 06 at 12:29 am
nice blog. I believe Sanju wont be given a chance if the judge wants india to learn a lesson. On the other hand, it could have implications on those who want to come back to life. They would definitely not want to spend their rest of life in jail. Can I say that the punishment has to be chose very carefully. And with all due respect, not showing major’s news does not intend to hurt any emotions.
Lets not bring media into all this. Both the news are of equal importance to me. As, salute to major who laid his life for terrorists. Also, an attempt has to be made remove terrorism from its root. Might be Sanju’s case could be seen as a step towards that. Lets wait and watch.
aj
20 Dec 06 at 12:48 am
Thanks AJ!
I think what we are gonna see in the future, not just in Sanju’s case, would be worth the wait.
I believe that India as a nation will see good things happening soon.
Chill!
SKPeta
20 Dec 06 at 6:44 am
i couldn’t synchronize with what u write; ur blog has too many
contradictions, i am bemused;
stithapragna
22 Dec 06 at 9:46 am
Dude. You are truly a lost soul. In your quest for objectivity and neutrality, you seem to have become a mix of cynical and apathetic. You might just soon lose yourself. For there is no universal truth. You can only get a perspective. But there is human sacrifice here, so damn it, take a side man! take a side! Whether Indian army killed some Kashmiris or not, whether India is ruled by corrupt politicians or not, whether majority of Indians are apathetic or not, it does not alter the greatness of sacrifice of this man.
Nicholas Rajan
22 Jan 07 at 4:56 pm
Hey guys, I got the same forwarded mail. When I ran a google search I learnt Major Manish Pitambare was killed in Anantnag while saving the life of his partner in an operation against Mohammad Ashraf Shah, commander of the Hizb-ul-Mujahideen’s south Kashmir division on November 27th 2006. He was awarded the Kirti Chakra on 25th of January. If so, then the media dont need to run the piece on Ausgust 22nd 2007, the day Sanjay Dutt was released from prison.
Before being judgemental let us examine the true facts.
Nasreen
10 Sep 07 at 12:24 am
Well, in reference to the above written text, I just have one thing to say, we all might forget who we are for the kind of life we live, but at the end of the day let us not bring in the concept of “Us vs Our Lifeless Side” because it is easy to speak and write flowery words but it is equally difficult to follow the same, the gentleman who wrote the above blog should understand here we are not to justify what is right and wrong because you don’t hold any right to justify anything either, if read between the lines, one can say the a man of your intelligence is so meek that he is justifying the actions of some stupids who have got an opportunity to be called media persons.
Also, Would like to clarify that I am not even talking about A major being killed or an actor is acquitted, here,I am talking about foolishness of media and foolishness of we the people of this country who believe in what is being told, because we can’t have what is shown so what’s the harm in living in our own fantasies… This reminds me of Khalil Gibran’s story of a Dumb wife. So freinds let’s live the reality and Sir, with due respect, stop defending media for your own cause.
Tylin
24 Aug 09 at 5:58 am
One massive problem with the statement:
Fact is they both are KILLERS. And if one doesn’t kill the other, the other will kill this one.
This is not true. It should be: if one (the major) doesn’t kill the other (the terrorist), the other will kill others like you and me.
This is the fact, that makes all the difference between the two KILLERS.
Anand
4 Nov 09 at 5:30 am
I don’t know where this particular blog writer lives. If in India, after 26/11 he might have understood whether both of them are killers or not?If not for the Indian army many of us cannot sit peacefully at home and blog as one pleases.This is not my perspective this is a fact.
Asha
1 Dec 09 at 2:03 am
Well said Anand, the writer seems not ready to take any side as he might be confused however will like to ask him if some contract killer kills your dear one will you hold no grudge against him saying that he was just doing his duty??? anyway I can say that many things depends and we are no one to give judgment as we are not mature enough to understand all the aspect of life.
Thanks Nasreen for bringing fact as I was searching for same and i came across this blog.
Harsh
15 Apr 10 at 6:49 am